The thriving underground economy of black markets for data derived from massive leaks

The Underbelly of Cybercrime: Insights from Synacktiv’s Analysis of Data Breaches

On May 28, 2026, Synacktiv, a French cybersecurity firm recognized by ANSSI as a PASSI-certified expert, released a comprehensive analysis detailing the burgeoning black markets for data obtained from massive leaks. Their findings reveal that stolen data has evolved from being a mere byproduct of cyberattacks to a critical operational resource actively traded within a structured cybercriminal ecosystem, designed to lower costs and increase the success rate of attacks on organizations.

Traditionally, data breaches have been viewed as isolated incidents, their severity gauged by the sensitivity of the exposed information at the time of the event. However, Synacktiv’s investigations indicate that this perspective is outdated. A breach does not indicate the end of the incident but rather initiates a lengthy exploitation cycle that can extend over years, involving distinct actors specialized in data collection, aggregation, automated testing, and resale.

According to Maxence Fossat, a cybersecurity expert at Synacktiv, the resulting underground economy mirrors the division of labor found in industrial subcontracting chains. Roles are stratified among collectors who use infostealers or direct intrusion, aggregators consolidating data from various leaks, automated testing providers who filter out only the truly exploitable access points, and specialized resellers who market these access points to other groups, particularly ransomware operators.

Timing and Value of Leaked Data

Not all data from a leak holds the same value at the same time. Session cookies represent the most urgent data category, as they can be exploited within hours following a compromise to bypass multi-factor authentication and access accounts. Their utility diminishes rapidly over time. User credentials, once sorted and tested, are organized into triples — URL/username/password, known as ULP lists — and resold en masse. Estimates suggest that in 2025, credential databases in circulation could contain between 1 and 2 billion entries, though this figure should be taken with caution due to the significant amount of outdated or duplicate data.

On the other hand, technical data follows a longer timeline. Internal documentation, infrastructure configurations, architectural schematics, and source code can be retained for years before being used to uncover vulnerabilities or prepare targeted attacks. Such exploitation typically involves advanced state-sponsored actors or economic intelligence operatives, whose operations usually go unnoticed despite their potential strategic impact.

The Shift in Initial Access Vectors

One of the most immediate effects of this underground economy on organizations is the shift in the initial access vector. Instead of employing complex intrusion techniques that trigger alerts, an increasing number of attacks identified by Synacktiv rely on valid credentials sourced from previous breaches or infostealer databases, often bolstered by password reuse practices. This method allows cybercriminals to enter information systems without activating signature- or reputation-based controls.

Moreover, leaked data enhances the credibility of social engineering attacks. By leveraging internal information gathered from prior breaches — such as account nomenclature, project names, or email exchanges — attackers craft phishing, vishing, or smishing schemes that are significantly more convincing than generic attempts.

The Role of Generative AI and Initial Access Brokers

The industrialization of these practices is further accelerated by two complementary drivers. The incorporation of automated tools and generative AI models empowers less technically skilled attackers to produce code, test credentials on a large scale, and exfiltrate substantial volumes of data, thereby lowering the entry barrier into this underground economy.

Initial Access Brokers (IABs) serve as a pivotal link in the cybercriminal value chain. Specializing in the identification and resale of compromised access, they enable other groups, particularly ransomware operators, to acquire initial access without needing to conduct reconnaissance or intrusion themselves. This division of labor increases the effectiveness of attacks and complicates attribution efforts.

A Long-Term Risk Underestimated by Organizations

Renaud Feil, co-founder and President of Synacktiv, encapsulates the critical issue: “Data breaches should be understood as events that contribute to a structured underground economic ecosystem. The mechanisms observed in attacks against individuals — account theft, identity fraud, phishing — are equally applicable to businesses, with amplified effects.”

The long-term persistence of risk is often the most underestimated aspect. Synacktiv notes instances where attacks rely on data from breaches that occurred several years prior. In other cases, exfiltrated data is used to maintain lasting access to information systems, either by retaining active credentials or installing backdoors that allow for re-entry after an initial compromise. Treating breaches as closed incidents at the moment of detection, rather than recognizing them as events within a protracted exploitation cycle, hinders organizations’ abilities to calibrate their monitoring measures accordingly.

Scroll to Top