The parliamentary inquiry committee estimates the software dependency of administrations at 1.5 billion euros

An investigation commission focusing on structural dependencies and systemic vulnerabilities in the digital sector has released its report after six months of work, including 45 hearings and testimonies from 112 individuals. The report estimates that French administrations spend €1.5 billion annually on software from non-European providers, of which €1 billion could be replaced immediately. It outlines 18 recommendations and 29 proposals aimed at mitigating this dependence.

Reporters Cyrielle Chatelain and Philippe Latombe directed the commission’s efforts towards two key areas: the dependence on cloud storage and data processing, and the control of critical software components by a small number of companies. Due to time constraints, issues such as cybersecurity, informational interference, and hardware infrastructure outside data centers were not addressed. The report indicates that nearly 80% of software purchases by central administrations go to US vendors, creating a widespread reliance on companies like Microsoft, VMware, and Oracle. In the private sector, spending on software and cloud services from American firms reaches €264 billion across Europe.

Philippe Latombe connects this work to a report on digital sovereignty published five years earlier. He references the recent restriction placed on access to AI models from Anthropic by the US Department of Commerce, an incident previously analyzed by IT Social, which suggested that this “kill switch” was primarily an export control, a legal administrative action with global implications rather than a mere technical switch. For the commission, such incidents now classify as significant risks.

Sovereign Cloud: The Primary Actionable Lever

Recommendation No. 3 urges companies to immediately migrate their sensitive data to solutions certified under SecNumCloud and to discontinue using services from US providers. The commission commends the effectiveness of the Cloud doctrine for state administrations and proposes its extension to all public entities. However, it highlights uneven implementation, with some social ministries, the justice system, and cultural sectors still using clouds outside the prescribed doctrine, while operators deemed vital remain largely hosted outside Europe.

Recommendation No. 9 mandates purchasing centers to disclose the actual nationality of the software vendors they represent, taking into account foreign legal obligations. The report provides a concrete example where the Ugap had to reprocess its data after classifying companies located in Ireland as European, despite their American ties, like Amazon. IT Social previously noted that the sovereignty of a hosting provider should be verified, not negotiated.

Legal and Budgetary Arsenal to Reduce Dependence

Among the 29 proposals, several target public procurement and funding. Proposal No. 15 establishes a European preference reminiscent of a Buy European Act. Proposal No. 10 mandates that open-source solutions become a requirement for public contracts in state administrations and public enterprises by January 1, 2030. Proposal No. 11 introduces a clause for source code escrow to ensure service continuity in case of vendor failure, while Recommendation No. 11 allocates part of the France 2030 funds and the French Tech 120 program to open-source providers meeting interoperability standards.

Other measures focus on specific entities. Proposal No. 19 suggests that the state hold certain shares, or golden shares, in Mistral AI and ChapsVision to maintain oversight in case of sale to a non-European group. Proposals No. 21 and 22 call for a moratorium and public control on data center projects that do not meet sovereignty imperatives. Proposal No. 28 goes further, advocating for the establishment of a fully-fledged Ministry of Digital Affairs.

Insights on Data Dependency Revealed by the Report

The report also quantifies the economic impact of this dependence. The value-added rate for large non-European platforms is at most 28%, compared to an average of 42% for the cloud sector. This disparity is attributed to an offshore business model that limits actual tax contributions in France. The digital services tax partially offsets this gap, but some non-European data center operators continue to evade it.

Regarding data protection, the report notes that the US government made over 5,500 disclosure requests to Microsoft in the second half of 2025 and more than 60,000 to Google, with 89% of those requests being fulfilled. In response, Recommendation No. 5 proposes the elimination of the one-stop-shop rule of the GDPR, transferring direct oversight of cross-border processing by major platforms to the European Data Protection Board, a mechanism currently viewed as overly dependent on the Irish authority.

A Report Lacking Legislative Guarantees

As a commission of inquiry, it holds no binding power; its recommendations serve as political guidance. The rapporteur herself acknowledged the limitations of the exercise, citing insufficient time to explore cyberattacks, information interference, or reliance on hardware components—topics earmarked for an upcoming resilience bill for critical infrastructures, anticipated to spark debate on September 21.

For IT departments, the immediate value lies not just in the 47 recommendations and proposals, but in the framework they provide today, such as using SecNumCloud as a purchasing criterion, verifying a vendor’s nationality beyond their billing address, and anticipating the risk of service disruption, which, as the commission admits, is now an operational reality rather than merely a theoretical concern.

Scroll to Top