One in eight French SMEs forgoes all cyber insurance, with no intention of subscribing to it

Cyber Risk Management in French SMEs: A Growing Concern Amid Decreasing Coverage

French small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) are adopting an empirical approach to managing cyber risks, often allocating minimal resources for protection while avoiding specialized insurance contracts. According to the latest annual survey by insurer Hiscox, there has been a notable decline in dedicated cyber insurance policies, a decreasing interest in coverage for AI-related risks, and one of the weakest preventive measures in Europe. Despite brokers reporting a growing market, this gap highlights the need for business leaders to scrutinize what their existing contracts truly cover.

As French SMEs face increasing and costlier cyberattacks, their cybersecurity budgets remain constrained, compounded by stricter insurer conditions since 2021. Hiscox’s tenth annual cybersecurity risk management report, released on September 15, reveals a drop in the percentage of French SMEs with dedicated cyber coverage from 33.6% to 27.6% within a year. Conducted by Wakefield Research between June 5 and June 17, 2026, the survey involved 6,800 cybersecurity decision-makers from organizations with fewer than 250 employees across ten countries, including France.

Victorine Bailleul, Head of Cyber and Tech offerings at Hiscox, notes a “widespread misunderstanding of the role of insurance.” She argues that too many French businesses believe their technical investments are sufficient, while a cyberattack can create financial, legal, and operational shockwaves that technology alone cannot mitigate. While the sponsor sells cyber insurance and may have commercial motives for her conclusions, her findings raise critical discussions in a market where data is available.

Dedicated Policies Yield to Multi-Risk Contracts

Hiscox points out that the decline in dedicated cyber insurance is accompanied by a rise in companies without any protection. The percentage of unprotected French SMEs rose from 39% to 45% in just one year, with only 55% of surveyed businesses reporting any form of coverage. Alarmingly, one in eight—12%—claims to have no coverage whatsoever and does not plan to obtain any, an increase from one in eleven last year. This trend is not isolated to France, with declines of 26 points in Portugal and 9 points in Spain and Ireland.

In the United States and the United Kingdom, where coverage rates remain higher, businesses are opting to realign their protection rather than relinquish it altogether. Nearly half are choosing comprehensive multi-risk contracts that include cyber coverage. This shift simplifies purchasing for smaller companies but raises questions about coverage limits and guarantees, which may be lower in a bundled policy compared to dedicated options.

In France, this trend remains minimal, with 33.1% of uninsured SMEs expressing plans to secure a dedicated cyber policy within the next twelve months, the highest percentage among surveyed countries. However, this intention lacks specificity, as the survey does not clarify reasons for forgoing coverage—whether due to price, insurer refusal, or budget reallocation—nor does it detail the nature of the remaining protections.

Brokerage Data Paints a Different Picture

Data collected by the AMRAE (French Risk Management Association) from brokers indicates an expanding market in the same segments. The AMRAE’s LUCY study, published on July 9, 2026, documents the cyber contracts taken out in 2025 through twelve brokers, one insurer, and the association of brokers. It reveals a 97% increase in insured businesses among medium-sized firms (those generating €10 to €50 million in revenue), 45% among smaller firms (€2 to €10 million), and 35% among microenterprises (under €2 million).

Despite this growth, the AMRAE also observes a price softening while claims frequency worsens. Total premiums dipped by 3% to €306 million, with the average premium rate for medium-sized companies falling by 7%. Conversely, payouts reached €83.2 million—a 53% increase—across 1,251 claims, nearly three times the number in 2024. However, the AMRAE admits that its method is less precise for smaller businesses, which often procure coverage directly from insurers outside their studied panel.

The two measurements—Hiscox’s survey of companies with fewer than 250 employees and AMRAE’s recorded contracts through brokers—assess different aspects and need not be contradictory. A growing intermediary market can coexist with an increasing number of small businesses lacking coverage, especially if new contracts primarily concentrate on already-aware enterprises. Neither source offers penetration rates reflective of the entire French economy, a critical statistic missing from the discussion.

One-Third of Insured Companies Lack AI Risk Coverage

For those SMEs that remain insured, Hiscox also evaluates the portion of contracts that cover AI-related risks. The report indicates that 69% of French policyholders have coverage encompassing these risks, compared to 74% across other surveyed European countries. Alarmingly, nearly half of French decision-makers—49%—identify data poisoning, which compromises the training data of AI models, as the foremost emerging threat over the next five years.

This concern resonates with respondents from the ten countries surveyed, where 17% recognize AI tools and software as potential entry points for successful attacks. Moreover, 32% plan to revise their cyber insurance contracts to ensure these risks are adequately covered. Hiscox warns that AI is already making phishing schemes more convincing and social engineering more targeted. For SMEs deploying AI assistants or tools connected to sensitive data, the absence of explicit guarantees places the burden of incidents involving these technologies squarely on the company, often leading to contentious discussions with insurers. Contracts established prior to the rise of generative assistants frequently overlook references to model manipulation, data leaks via third-party tools, or fraud supported by synthetic voices. The anticipated revisions from a third of respondents imply that companies will need to take stock of their operational AI tools—a task many small businesses struggle to maintain.

French SMEs Invest Only Half as Much in Cybersecurity Compared to Peers

According to Hiscox’s report, this retreat from insurance dovetails with limited preventive efforts. On average, French SMEs allocate $32,700 annually towards cyber resilience—approximately €29,700—significantly less than their counterparts in Spain ($80,900), Italy ($73,800), and the UK ($59,700), with an average of $51,000 across Europe. The gap is as stark as 2.5 times compared to Spain and 1.8 times compared to the UK, with the Netherlands and Portugal spending even less at $26,400 and $10,700, respectively.

This dual retreat leaves attacked companies grappling with severe consequences detailed in the Hiscox survey. Among those targeted, 40% encountered payment diversion fraud, with reputational damage referenced by 19.8%. Hiscox attributes 26% of incidents to human error, such as responding to phishing emails. On average, business interruptions last 24.5 hours, although 66.8% of incidents resolve within a day. Furthermore, 96% of impacted companies report effects on their strategic or financial standing, with 37% of employees experiencing significant stress.

Payment diversion fraud, the most common incident according to Hiscox, often stems from CEO fraud or false supplier schemes. Such risks can be mitigated with low-cost validation procedures. This type of fraud also highlights a key difference in how cyber and multi-risk contracts handle it, with some redirecting it towards distinct fraud insurance.

For financial officers or chief information security officers at SMEs, renegotiating a cyber contract becomes a pressure-driven rather than instinctive action. Their initial check should focus on the actual content of the cyber component within a multi-risk policy, considering limits, deductibles, payment fraud clauses, and crisis management costs. Next, they should ensure the explicit inclusion of claims related to AI tools, followed by evaluating the relationship between premiums and prevention measures, which insurers increasingly tie to access and pricing. With premiums trending downward, the current market presents a timely opportunity for renegotiation.

Scroll to Top