CADA and Cloud Sovereignty: France Digitale Fears a Level 3 Open to Non-European Providers

France Digitale Advocates for Enhanced EU Preferences in Cloud and AI Development Act

France Digitale, the association representing over 2,000 French startups, investors, and incubators, is making a strong case for prioritizing European suppliers under the proposed Cloud and AI Development Act (CADA). The organization claims that, as currently structured, almost all providers would qualify for Level 3, which could unintentionally favor large corporations that can afford substantial investments within the European Union. France Digitale is calling for a more robust preference system for public buyers, while avoiding new constraints for private enterprises.

On June 3, 2026, the European Commission introduced the CADA, which establishes four tiers of guarantees for cloud services procured by the public sector. These tiers range from data localization within the EU to ensuring there is no third-party interference. The proposal is now under consideration by the European Parliament and Council, alongside an open consultation initiated by the Commission.

In its recent sixteen-page response, France Digitale supports a unified regulatory framework over the current 27 national approaches. However, the organization urges that three distinct criteria be evaluated separately: the European origin of the provider, the guarantee of their service, and the specific market requirements.

Level 3: Within Reach for Most Providers

According to a preliminary assessment cited by France Digitale, the majority of suppliers could attain Level 3 status, making it difficult for European providers to distinguish themselves. The association argues that this situation contradicts the intent of the legislation, which aims to increase the market share of European firms. They propose a more accessible Level 2, including hybrid offerings that carry safeguards against unauthorized data access; a Level 3 dedicated to European suppliers who maintain control over their technology; and a stringent Level 4, requiring complete legal and operational oversight within Europe.

France Digitale also clarifies who qualifies as a European provider. Such entities must be headquartered in Europe and not be directly or indirectly controlled by a third-country entity, as defined by the European regulation regarding concentrations. Notably, a minority stake held by foreign investors would not disqualify a company. Conversely, any joint venture subject to decisive influence from a non-European partner would be excluded from Levels 3 and 4 due to ongoing exposure to that partner’s jurisdiction and business decisions.

European Preference: Limited to 15 Points on 120

The current text caps the weight of the European added value in offer evaluations at 15 points out of a total of 120. France Digitale is calling for the removal of this ceiling, advocating instead for buyers to determine weighting based on the market’s importance. Additionally, they want this criterion applied across all tenders, regardless of the required level. According to the association, the existing criteria could inadvertently benefit non-European players capable of investing in the EU, while continuing to favor large investors.

Among the criteria that France Digitale seeks to tighten are the exceptions referenced in Articles 18 and 30, which they believe should be limited to Levels 1 and 2. The association supports the goal of reserving 25% of public contracts for SMEs but insists on clarification regarding whether this is measured by contract value, number of contracts, or actual usage.

Encryption and Resilience: Notable Omissions

France Digitale has identified two significant gaps in the annex detailing the criteria for the levels. Notably, it does not mention encryption, allowing a foreign-controlled provider to comply with data localization at Level 2 while potentially enabling their parent company access through backdoor software, key escrow, or admin access. The association is advocating for mandatory encryption both at rest and in transit, with keys managed by the client or a trusted third party, starting from Level 2.

Additionally, the criteria lack provisions for resilience, failing to require geographic dispersion of data centers, link redundancy, or recovery objectives. A service certified at Levels 3 or 4, but hosted in a single data center, could become vulnerable to incidents such as outages, natural disasters, or cyberattacks.

Oversight of Major Providers Assigned to the Commission

The proposal assigns the evaluation of suppliers to national authorities, a move that France Digitale sees as potentially problematic. They highlight the risk that states hosting the European headquarters of large non-European providers—and depending on their investments and taxes—could exert inappropriate influence over these evaluations. They also flag the looming threat of tariffs targeting countries that adopt digital regulations or taxes. To mitigate this, the association proposes that the Commission take on the evaluation of larger providers, similar to the oversight applied to major platforms under the Digital Markets Act (DMA) and the Digital Services Act (DSA).

France Digitale further expresses concern about the stagnation of the European Cybersecurity Certification framework for cloud services (EUCS), upon which the higher levels of CADA depend. The framework is not yet established, and existing national regimes, like France’s SecNumCloud or Germany’s C5, are inconsistent. The association advocates for a deadline to either implement this framework or replace it with a unified European standard.

Prioritizing Public Buyers while Leaving Private Firms Untethered

France Digitale argues that the migration obligation should primarily impact government administrations and be extended from 12 to 24 months, while remaining voluntary for the private sector. They oppose Article 31(3), which would allow the Commission to extend these requirements to critical sectors such as finance and healthcare. Instead, they request a presumption of compliance for services already certified under sector-specific regimes, such as healthcare data hosting.

For public sector CIOs, the CADA will delineate the required level for each use case, signaling the start of discussions surrounding the definition of a European actor, joint ventures, and the weight of preference granted. While France Digitale is advocating for stronger preferences that would benefit its suppliers, the association acknowledges the concern of its startups that rely on non-European infrastructure—worrying that stringent requirements could alienate them from public contracts.

Scroll to Top