Musk wants to leave without 1,000 billion: would Tesla survive the abandonment of its own creator

Elon Musk may leave Tesla if he does not secure a $1 trillion compensation plan. This ultimatum, akin to a pressure tactic, raises a staggering question: what would become of Tesla without its star founder?

The $1 Trillion Plan: Crazy Promise or Winning Strategy?

Firstly, the compensation plan proposed to Elon Musk is anything but ordinary. It’s not just a simple bonus; it’s a superstructure of discounted stock, spread over a decade. Musk could potentially earn up to $1 trillion, provided he drives Tesla to almost unattainable heights: $8.5 trillion in market capitalization, 12 million vehicles sold, 1 million humanoid robots, and global dominance in AI.

On one hand, for some investors, it’s a visionary bet that aligns Musk’s interests with those of shareholders. On the other hand, it’s an exhibition of megalomania that undermines the credibility of the board of directors. Ultimately, can a company truly be built around one individual?

A Board of Directors Under Influence, Losing Its Compass?

Furthermore, the letter from Robyn Denholm, chairwoman of the board, drives the point home: without this plan, Musk could walk away. Tesla might then “lose its time, talent, and vision.” This statement feels more like emotional blackmail than sound governance.

Moreover, the issue is that this board has already been overturned by a Delaware court. In January, a court annulled Musk’s previous compensation plan, deeming it excessive, negotiated by directors who were too close to him. Thus, the board’s independence is seriously in question. And without safeguards, the company’s strategy could veer into irrationality.

Tesla Without Musk: Dream of Autonomy or Disaster Scenario?

Now, let’s imagine: Musk leaves Tesla. Would it really be the end of the world? Yes and no. Today, Tesla is an impressive industrial machine, capable of producing over 1.8 million vehicles a year. Its brand remains strong, and its logistics network is well-established. On paper, the company can survive without its founder.

However, in reality, Musk embodies the DNA of Tesla. He is the one who electrifies the markets, sells the ambition, and attracts top talent. A sudden departure could trigger a stock market collapse, an internal crisis of confidence, and a loss of strategic direction. Because Musk, controversial as he may be, remains the emotional and narrative engine of Tesla.

What Alternatives to Reassure Without Succumbing?

Finally, the real question is: how do you keep Musk without giving in to all his whims? Several avenues emerge. First, a more balanced negotiation, with realistic goals and a plan approved by truly independent directors. Next, preparing for the post-Musk era: building a strong, credible, visible executive team. And most importantly, re-grounding Tesla in sound governance practices, where value creation does not solely depend on one individual.

In the long run, Tesla will have to prove that it can grow without a guru, even if that means scaling back its ambitions. Because a company, no matter how visionary, cannot rest indefinitely on the shoulders of one person, no matter how brilliant.

Scroll to Top