Elon Musk promises a more “authentic” alternative to Wikipedia with Grokipedia. However, right from its launch, the tool relies on content from the encyclopedia he criticizes. Let’s break it down.
Musk Launches Grokipedia to Compete with Wikipedia, But Still Relies on It
Elon Musk has never hidden his skepticism about Wikipedia. According to him, the encyclopedia is too biased, influenced by interest groups or activists. To address this, he has launched Grokipedia, a platform touted as more “honest” and verified by the AI of xAI, Grok.
However, there’s a catch. While browsing Grokipedia.com, one quickly realizes that many articles are directly inspired by Wikipedia, sometimes word for word. The case of the MacBook Air is particularly striking. The content is identical, with only a banner noting that it is an adaptation under a Creative Commons license. Ironically, to provide “the truth,” Musk starts by recycling the very source he criticizes.
Wikipedia Responds: Between Transparency, Community, and Declining Traffic
The Wikimedia Foundation, which manages Wikipedia, has not been slow to respond. In a statement relayed by The Verge, it indicates that it is “trying to understand how Grokipedia works”. It takes the opportunity to remind everyone of its unique model: content written by passionate volunteers, continuously reviewed, without AI.
Yet, not everything is rosy. The foundation acknowledges that its traffic is declining. Internet users are consulting Wikipedia less and less, opting instead for conversational AIs or explanatory videos. This decline could jeopardize the model by reducing the number of contributors and donations.
A Debate Between Collaborative Knowledge and Algorithmic Truth
The standoff between Musk and Wikipedia reveals a deeper issue: what kind of knowledge do we want for the future? On one side, Wikipedia remains a human, open, decentralized project. On the other, Grokipedia offers a more technological, automated, AI-verified approach, where truth is faster and “purer.”
But can we really oppose the two? After all, Grok itself relies on Wikipedia to form its responses. One does not exist without the other. It may not be a conflict, but rather a necessary coexistence. Musk promises an independent version 1.0 by the end of 2025. In the meantime, it’s hard to label it as genius or a scam.
What This Means for Us: Better Understanding and Choosing Our Sources
Behind this encyclopedia war lies a genuine question of usage. For us, readers, the real revolution isn’t about choosing between Wikipedia and Grokipedia, but learning to decode sources, cross-reference information, and remain curious.
Wikipedia has its limitations, but it also has a vibrant community. Grokipedia is promising, yet still unclear. The ideal? Navigate between the two, while maintaining our critical thinking. Because neither AI nor volunteers should have the final say—it’s our collective intelligence that matters most.


