Apple loses appeal against the Digital Markets Act and remains subject to European rules
Apple has faced another judicial setback in Europe. The EU Court has dismissed the company’s appeal against its designation as a “gatekeeper” under the Digital Markets Act (DMA). This ruling confirms that the App Store and iOS must comply with the obligations set by European regulations aimed at increasing competition among major digital platforms.
This decision not only affects Apple but also strengthens one of the pillars of the DMA, which continues to reshape the balance of power between Brussels and American tech giants.
Court Rejects Apple’s Main Argument
At the heart of the appeal was a seemingly technical issue with significant consequences. Apple argued that each of its ecosystems — iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, and Apple TV — should be treated as a distinct service.
According to Apple, this approach would have limited the application scope of the DMA.
The judges did not accept this argument.
They believe that the various versions of the App Store essentially serve the same purpose: connecting developers with users. This interpretation confirms that the entirety of Apple’s ecosystem can be considered when enforcing the Digital Markets Act rules.
The iMessage Issue Remains Open
However, not all aspects of the appeal were reviewed on their merits. The judges ruled Apple’s arguments regarding iMessage to be inadmissible. This part of the case has been dismissed without any ruling on the substance of the debate.
The judgment pertains solely to Apple’s designation as a gatekeeper and the obligations that arise from it.
What the “Gatekeeper” Status Means for Apple
The Digital Markets Act targets platforms deemed essential access points between businesses and consumers. For Apple, this status entails several significant obligations:
- Allowing alternative app stores on iOS
- Enabling developers to direct users to external payment systems
- Opening certain services of its ecosystem to competitors
Some of these measures are already in effect within the European Union. Apple now permits the installation of alternative app stores and the use of external payment links. However, the company has accompanied these possibilities with new commissions, additional procedures, and warning messages that many developers argue significantly diminish their appeal.
A Crucial Ruling for Brussels
This ruling carries implications beyond just Apple’s case. The continuance of the “gatekeeper” classification bolsters the entire legal framework established by the European Commission since the Digital Markets Act took effect in May 2023.
The sanctions outlined in this law can amount to 10% of a company’s global annual revenue in cases of non-compliance with the imposed obligations.
This decision also strengthens the Commission’s position in ongoing investigations against Apple, Google, and Meta.
Apple is Not the Only Company Challenging the DMA
Since the regulation’s implementation, several major American companies have filed appeals in European courts. Apple, Meta, and ByteDance are each seeking to limit the scope of the new rules.
However, the outcomes have been mixed.
Last month, the EU Court partially sided with Meta by removing Marketplace from the DMA’s scope while keeping Messenger among the affected services. In this context, Apple’s defeat appears particularly significant.
A Battle Far From Over
Apple still has the option to appeal to the Court of Justice of the European Union, the highest court in the bloc. Such a procedure would focus solely on legal questions and not involve a re-evaluation of the facts.
Until a potential ruling, the obligations stipulated by the DMA continue to apply.
This case comes amidst the European Commission’s concerns that certain App Store practices still limit developers’ ability to direct users to cheaper payment solutions. Additionally, Apple has delayed launching several features in Europe, citing interoperability requirements imposed by the regulations.
A Conflict Beyond Legal Boundaries
Beyond the legal dispute, this decision highlights the growing tensions between Brussels and large American tech companies. Washington frequently criticizes European regulations perceived as particularly burdensome for American firms, while the Commission defends the DMA as a tool to re-establish balanced competition in digital markets.
Apple maintains that some obligations imposed by the law could undermine the privacy and security standards that the company argues are crucial selling points of the iPhone.
The ruling made this week does not resolve this fundamental issue. It merely confirms that Apple falls under the scope of the Digital Markets Act, allowing the debate on the real implications of these rules to continue in the political, economic, and likely judicial arenas.


