Researchers discover attacks against Google passkeys: should we be worried

Researchers discover attacks on Google’s passkeys: should we be worried?

Presented as the future of authentication, passkeys were meant to put an end to compromised passwords, phishing, and data breaches. Google has claimed for several years that this technology cannot be copied or accidentally transmitted to an attacker. However, a new study shows that the reality is more nuanced.

Cybersecurity researchers have revealed a series of attacks dubbed Pass-ta-key, capable of circumventing some protections of passkeys synchronized via Google Password Manager. While the cryptography remains intact, the research demonstrates that a computer already infected with malware can compromise the ecosystem surrounding these identifiers.

Passkeys Are Not Broken… But Their Environment Can Be

The first important point is that the researchers did not manage to break the cryptographic technology of passkeys. The attacks instead target the way Google manages trust in a device, the synchronization of passkeys, account recovery, and the process of validating the user’s identity.

In other words, the issue does not concern the cryptographic key itself, but rather the software infrastructure that utilizes it. All the described attacks, however, require one essential condition: malware must already be present on the victim’s Windows computer.

When Malware Impersonates Your Computer

The first method, called Pass-ta-key, exploits the trust relationship between Chrome, the TPM (Trusted Platform Module), and Google Password Manager. The malware can use the hardware identity of the computer to request valid authentication from Google’s cloud service.

What’s most concerning is that this operation does not require any biometric authentication, PIN codes, device unlocking, or victim interaction. To Google, the request appears to come from an already trusted computer.

The researchers also found that some websites correctly checked whether the user had actually validated their identity, while others accepted the login despite the absence of this verification. eBay has since patched this vulnerability following its disclosure.

An Even More Advanced Attack

The researchers also described a more sophisticated variant called Silver Pass-ta-key. This technique could allow an attacker to register a validation key that they control. This key is then recognized as legitimate proof that the user confirmed their identity via a PIN code or biometric authentication.

The attacker could then access the account from another computer, even after the original device is no longer connected.

The Most Concerning Scenario: Recovering the Master Key

The third attack, Golden Pass-ta-key, is by far the most alarming. It targets the master key used by Google to encrypt all passkeys synchronized within an account. Researchers initially discovered that this key appeared in clear text in some of Chrome’s internal logs.

Google rapidly removed this exposure.

However, according to researchers, this key still temporarily appears in Chrome’s RAM during certain operations like registering a new device or account recovery.

A sufficiently sophisticated malware could then retrieve this master key, decrypt the synchronized passkeys, and potentially access future passkeys associated with the same account. Even more troubling, researchers note that Google currently offers no mechanism for revoking or renewing this master key once it has been compromised.

Despite Everything, Passkeys Are Much Safer Than Passwords

These findings do not mean that passkeys have become useless. They remain vastly superior to traditional passwords against the most common attacks: phishing, password reuse, compromised databases, and brute-force attacks.

What this study reveals is that no authentication method is entirely invulnerable once a device is compromised. In this scenario, the malware does not attack the passkeys themselves but exploits the mechanisms that allow them to be used.

A New Reality for Cybersecurity

The study underscores a fundamental rule of cybersecurity: the strength of a technology depends as much on its environment as on its encryption. Passkeys are still one of the best alternatives to traditional passwords today. However, they cannot protect a computer that is already infected with malware capable of interacting directly with the browser and the operating system.

For Google, this research serves as an important signal. After strengthening Chrome by removing certain sensitive information from internal logs, the next challenge is to further secure the synchronization and recovery mechanisms. As passkeys become the standard, it is precisely these peripheral components that will attract increasing attention from researchers… and cybercriminals.


Scroll to Top