Long before algorithms, data centers, and the discussions surrounding artificial intelligence emerged, some individuals had already noticed a troubling phenomenon: humanity’s increasing dependence on machines. Yet, at that time, it was not engineers or scientists doing the observing, but rather a simple shepherd.
In 1863, Samuel Butler Dares to Apply Darwin’s Theory to Machines and Imagines That They Could Evolve Without Humans
When Butler’s text was published in 1863, the context was immediately surprising. At that time, from New Zealand, Samuel Butler released Darwin among the Machines, an unsettling essay for its era. Right from the start, he proposed a simple yet explosive idea: to apply the mechanisms of evolution not to living beings, but to the machines crafted by humans.
Butler observes the still rudimentary industrial tools and discerns a clear logic: perfection, transmission of improvements, and the elimination of inefficient models. In other words, each innovation is not isolated; instead, it exists within a continuum, as if machines were already following their own evolutionary path.
This hypothesis raises a fundamental doubt. If machines evolve, what role remains for humans? According to Butler, humans could merely be an intermediate stage, potentially surpassed by their own creations. This is a dizzying intuition expressed well before the age of electricity or computing.
Machines Compared to Pets to Show How Humanity Becomes Gradually Dependent on Its Own Creations
To make his point more accessible, Butler employs an evocative image: that of domesticated animals. Initially, machines seem like obedient assistants. They help, relieve, and accelerate tasks. Gradually, society organizes itself around them by developing maintenance, energy, infrastructures, and a commitment to permanent optimization.
However, the shift is as subtle as it is profound. As machines become indispensable, one question arises: who truly depends on whom? Butler envisions systems capable of self-regulation, operating without direct human intervention. At that precise moment, he warns, humanity begins to relinquish its dominant position.
From Dune to Matrix, How This 19th-Century Idea Shaped All of Science Fiction and Our Contemporary Fears
Over time, Butler’s ideas did not fade away. On the contrary, they slowly permeate popular culture and feed into grand narratives of science fiction. In Dune, humanity engages in total war against the thinking machines during the famous Butlerian Jihad. This term is not trivial; it is a direct homage to Butler’s foundational thoughts.
Similarly, in Matrix, this anxiety takes on a different form. Humans become resources, integrated into a system that surpasses them. Later, Isaac Asimov, through his laws of robotics, attempts to envision rational safeguards against this central fear: the loss of control. Yet, long before these works, Butler had already laid the philosophical groundwork for such narratives.
With Erewhon, Samuel Butler Asks a Timely Question: Should Technology Be Limited for Survival?
In 1872, Samuel Butler logically extends his reflection in Erewhon. In this novel, he describes a society that makes a radical choice: to destroy all recent technology to ensure its survival. This move is neither superstitious nor irrational; rather, it is based on a cold analysis of the risks associated with unchecked progress. Even today, the question remains strikingly relevant: how far is humanity willing to delegate its intelligence?
As a machine gradually learns, decides, and optimizes itself, where does real power lie? More than a century and a half later, the concerns raised by a 19th-century shepherd still resonate with alarming modernity. Sometimes, the most insightful warnings arise far from laboratories, found in the patient observation of a changing world.



